It’s not about babies. Abortion restrictions are about power.
Anita ChabriaApril 11, 2023
The toes, the clothes and, oh, the smell of a newborn.
Babies are cute, which is exactly what makes babies such powerful political forces, and abortion such a divisive issue.
But of course abortion isn’t really about the babies, is it? Because we have enough babies living without health care, starving, stuck in foster care without
prospects of
adoption. Few anti-abortion people spend their weekends protesting that reality.
are abortion restrictions
about power, especially dominance over black and brown women. And even tilting
Roe v. Wade Roe v. Wade
last summer that didn’t drive home
kinda like that
much like
Fridays
ruling of an ultra-conservative judge in Texas
whose court order, if in effect, would prevent access to it
the safest and most commonly used drug for chemical abortions
towards the end of
this week.
“Misogyny among certain parts of our culture knows no bounds,” says Senator Nancy Skinner,
a Berkeley Democrat
and head of the
Caucus for California Legislative Women
told me.
I can’t argue. We are, as she put it,
in a dark time
where misogyny is “treacherous and anchored in morality.”
That ruling in Texas is now the subject of intense politics
and legal
maneuvering that in the coming days could accelerate an appeal to the majority anti-abortion Supreme Court. At issue is the alleged risk of a drug called mifepristone used in combination with a second drug for more than half of the
chemical
all abortions in the US
Despite the alleged concerns of federal judge Matthew Kacsmaryk, who in his ruling eschews the term fetus in favor of “unborn
humane
and “unborn child,”
mifepristone
has been used for over 22 years and is considered by medical providers to be so effective and safe that women can use it in the privacy of their own home until about the 10th week of pregnancy.
What’s the point.
This statement is not about safety. It’s about taking away privacy from abortions and forcing women into the public eye where they can be monitored and controlled.
Since
Roe v. Wade Roe v. Wade
was overturned, abortion is banned in 13 states, according to the Guttmacher Institute, a reproductive and sexual health think tank. Two other states have near-bans, creating a bloc of Southern states where women have no recourse, often not even in cases of rape or incest.
Guttmacher also reports that in the first few months since Roe was
overturned
At least 66 clinics in 15 states closed or stopped performing abortions, leaving nearly 30% of women
of reproductive age
in the US with limited opportunities to obtain one.
Chemical abortion, in some cases with mail delivery of the medication, was a life saver.
A chemical abortion can still be safely induced with just the second drug, misoprostol. But that one-drug regimen isn’t as effective
(though still very effective)
and can lead to more cramps. Simply put, it works, but it’s not the gold standard of the two-drug option.
Because it is slightly less effective and can cause more pain, it could lead more women to seek medical attention.
other
since some hospitals
in states with an abortion ban
Even refusing care for miscarriages can pose a deadly threat to a complication.
Forcing women
in a less effective and possibly more public and dangerous method
of medication abortion
is an atrocity meant to frighten women and make them fear the consequences.
“This kind of confusion and fear is not only clear that it’s going to be nearly impossible to have an abortion, but it’s definitely a deliberate intent,” says Mia Bloom.
Bloom is a professor of extremism at Georgia State University
,
and an expert on far-right forces creeping into power in the United States. When it comes to abortion, she sees
the prohibitions as tentacles of white nationalism and racism.
Bloom points out that wealthy women will find ways to travel for an abortion.
That makes
poor women, especially black and brown women who live hundreds of miles from a state where abortion is still legal,
the real goals of
this court ruling and
the grind of
new laws restricting abortion
in Republican-controlled states
.
Women, especially women of color, have become politically and economically powerful, a circumstance that threatens the patriarchal norms that
dominated
our power structures since the
Founding Fathers Founding Fathers
conveniently forget about the potential rights of the
Founding Mothers Founding Mothers
.
The Center for American Progress, a nonpartisan policy institute, found that between 2000 and 2019, the
resident
voting population of women of color increased by 59%
a profit of more than
13.5 million potential votes, the majority of which would probably go uncast
a Donald
Trump or
Ron
DeSantis.
Black women “basically put Joe Biden in office and they’re the reason we didn’t have a red wave in 2022,” Bloom told me. “So if you’re Harlan Crow sitting there thinking about these things long term, keeping black and brown women poor and pregnant and dependent on the system has taken a long time.”
–
term implications for the ballot box.”
Poor women with children can’t stand in line for hours to vote, she insists. Harlan
Crow is the billionaire collector of Nazi memorabilia who is friends with Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas, in case you missed last week’s big reveal of their friendship. You may recall that Thomas wrote a terrifying concurring opinion on Roe that suggested the same logic
that served as a base
for that decision could be used to overturn precedents protecting access to birth control, sexual privacy and same-sex marriages.
But one panic at a time.
The pronunciation of Kacsmaryk is
a
wake up hard
phone call
that “democracy is fragile,” Skinner said.
She has a granddaughter and now worries about what that child’s future will be like, perhaps one “where she would have to think twice about where she would go to work, where she would go to school,” Skinner said.
Bloom goes one step further in that darkness,
sew the pieces together
of this
dictatorial dictatorial
monster who is the new Republican
party party
. “It’s all part of this Christo-fascist agenda to target minorities,” she said. “Controlling women’s bodies, controlling sexuality, also means controlling the sexuality of gays, transgender people, everything [LGBTQ] letters.”
So Kacsmaryk’s statement is a beginning, not an end.
Erwin Chemerinsky, dean of the UC Berkeley School of Law, said he is hopeful the Texas ruling will be reversed because it is so extreme and out of sync with court precedent.
But if it isn’t, then it is
false
logic, especially that “unborn child” language,
opens a Pandora’s box with its misery and evil aimed at those who have long fought, with some success, for equality and justice.
Chemerinsky said so
female
birth control could be targeted soon, perhaps after the long term
Griswold v. Connecticut Griswold v. Connecticut
decide that
established case law
about reproductive privacy. Also at risk would be the
Laurens v. Texas Lawrence v. Texas
other
Obergefell v. Hodges Obergefell v Hodges
decisions that Judge Thomas singled out in his own
Roe Roe
opinion, which protects same-sex couples from discrimination.
Julia Spiegel, Gov. Deputy Legal Secretary. Gavin Newsom calls the current moment “incredibly alarming and concerning”.
She has spent the past few months helping California plan the Texas ruling, work culminating in Monday’s announcement that the state has purchased a supply of misoprostol that could provide about 12,000 abortions if needed.
and has the ability to get two 2 million pills, enough for nearly 100,000 abortions in total
. Not only does the state offer that supply for free if the drug were to become scarce, it has also offered a template to other states on its purchase order so others can follow suit.
the
cache
is an “insurance plan,” she said
safe, legal and affordable abortion
in California for all women, those who live here and those who have to travel here for care.
That kind of reassurance and action is critical right now because there are plenty of women and girls out there who are pregnant, scared and unsure of their options.
Even if the Texas ruling is ultimately struck down
is it the new normal that the far right continues to attack women and other vulnerable groups.
And it must become the new normal for those of us who believe in civil rights and democracy to be just as loud and forceful as those who prefer to exercise their power unchecked.
Because while babies are cute, authoritarianism isn’t.